Skip to main content

User account menu

  • Log in
  • Rss
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
Shopping cart 0
Cart

Search

Search
Home HubCitySPOKES
  • Post
    • Leaderboard
    • Post Dashboard
    • Payment Settings
  • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Monthly Website Statistics
    • Our Staff
    • Privacy Policy
    • Rack Locations
    • Submit News
  • Most Read
    • Most Read This Week
    • Most Read This Month
    • Most Read This Year
    • Most Read All Time
  • Most Recent
  • More News
    • Cartoons
    • Documents
    • Videos
    • Crime
    • Education
      • Hattiesburg Schools
      • Lamar County Schools
      • Petal Schools
      • Southern Miss
      • William Carey
    • Features
    • Politics
    • Public Notices
    • Hattiesburg
    • Lamar County
    • Petal
    • Health
  • Sports
    • High School
      • Forrest County AHS
      • Hattiesburg Tigers
      • Lamar Christian Lions
      • Lumberton Panthers
      • North Forrest
      • Oak Grove Warriors
      • PCS Bobcats
      • Petal Panthers
      • Purvis Tornadoes
      • Sacred Heart
      • Sumrall Bobcats
    • College/Universities
      • Jones College Bobcats
      • PRCC Wildcats
      • Southern Miss
      • William Carey
  • E-Editions
    • Newspaper E-Edition
    • Magazine E-Edition
    • Special Section E-Editions
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Comments
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Polls
    • Submit a Letter to the Editor
    • Benny Hornsby
    • Elijah Jones
    • Robert St. John
    • Clark Hicks
    • Rick Cleveland
    • Wes Brooks
    • Joshua Wilson
    • Jamie Massengale
  • Advertising
    • Ad Rates
    • Ad Staff
  • Calendar
  • Obituaries
    • Submit an Obituary
  • Social
    • Anniversaries/Birthdays
    • Engagements/Weddings
    • Schools
    • Submit an Anniversary
    • Submit a Birth
    • Submit an Engagement
    • Submit School News
    • Submit a Wedding
  • Subscribe
  • Signature
    • Happenings
    • Lifestyle
      • Cuisine
      • Fashion
      • Festival South
      • Film
      • Music
    • Neighbors
      • Meet Your Neighbor
      • Signature Q&A
  • State

Domain menu for HubCitySPOKES (main)

  • Post
    • Leaderboard
    • Post Dashboard
    • Payment Settings
  • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Monthly Website Statistics
    • Our Staff
    • Privacy Policy
    • Rack Locations
    • Submit News
  • Most Read
  • Most Recent
  • More News
    • Cartoons
    • Documents
    • Videos
    • Crime
    • Education
      • Hattiesburg Schools
      • Lamar County Schools
      • Petal Schools
      • Southern Miss
      • William Carey
    • Features
    • Politics
    • Public Notices
    • Hattiesburg
    • Lamar County
    • Petal
    • Health
  • Sports
    • High School
      • Forrest County AHS
      • Hattiesburg Tigers
      • Lamar Christian Lions
      • Lumberton Panthers
      • North Forrest
      • Oak Grove Warriors
      • PCS Bobcats
      • Petal Panthers
      • Purvis Tornadoes
      • Sacred Heart
      • Sumrall Bobcats
    • College/Universities
      • Jones College Bobcats
      • PRCC Wildcats
      • Southern Miss
      • William Carey
  • E-Editions
    • Newspaper E-Edition
    • Magazine E-Edition
    • Special Section E-Editions
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Comments
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Polls
    • Submit a Letter to the Editor
    • Benny Hornsby
    • Elijah Jones
    • Robert St. John
    • Clark Hicks
    • Rick Cleveland
    • Wes Brooks
    • Joshua Wilson
    • Jamie Massengale
  • Advertising
  • Calendar
  • Obituaries
  • Social
  • Subscribe
  • Signature
    • Happenings
    • Lifestyle
      • Cuisine
      • Fashion
      • Festival South
      • Film
      • Music
    • Neighbors
      • Meet Your Neighbor
      • Signature Q&A
  • State

HATTIESBURG’S CONFEDERATE MONUMENT: It's Time - Part IV: Decision Time on the Monument

By Dr. Benjamin Morris and William Sturkey , READ MORE > 1,103 Reads
On Wed, 10/28/2020 - 11:01 AM

It is finally time. The election is already underway, as across the country voters are casting their ballots to decide America’s leadership. It’s been a journey – readers of our previous columns have joined us as we traveled to the late 1800s, to the pivotal year of 1910, and then to the 1950s and ‘60s, all in an effort to understand the history of Hattiesburg’s Confederate monument.

In our final column, we wanted to adjust our lens to focus not on the past, but on the present – and most importantly, the future. On Nov. 3, voters will face a question on the ballot known as county-wide Ballot Measure #4. The question reads as follows: “Please vote yes or no on whether the Confederate monument should be moved to a more suitable location.” Back in July, we made our position clear: that given its historical origin in an era of racial disenfranchisement and as an act of perpetuating racial injustice, the Confederate monument has no place on the grounds of an American courthouse, and that both the monument itself and area residents as well are best served by its relocation to a more neutral setting.

Today, we’re here to make the case one final time. We’ll start, however, by responding to the most common objections to its relocation.

Argument #1: “This monument, and others like it, are symbols of heritage, not hate.” Without a doubt, this argument is offered in public debates more than any other. Unfortunately, it has multiple flaws. First: it constructs a faulty framework, suggesting a false binary that distorts the documented origin of the monument in question. We know that local folks have pride in their Confederate ancestry, a pride that is heartfelt and personal. But as we showed in our second article, according to the secessionists themselves, there is no ambiguity in Mississippi over why our state seceded – to preserve the institution of slavery – and this monument (like its kin) was erected to honor that effort. You can read its words, etched in stone, for yourself. Moreover, it was erected during a time when those same veterans who had lost the Civil War decided to wage it anew on legal grounds. Descendants of Confederates today may genuinely bear no ill-will towards African-Americans, but the same cannot be true of those who conceived of, financed, and built this monument.

A more accurate framing of this debate would focus not only on heritage or hate but instead citizenship. This monument reflects a period in American and Southern history when large numbers of its citizens were denied the right to vote. Why should we continue to honor a monument that expressly celebrates that?

Argument #2: “Removing this monument amounts to revising or erasing history.” If only it were that easy! There are several responses here. First, on a basic level, this is logically impossible, because in order to formulate any arguments that reassess Confederate symbolism, historians have had to research the primary sources that gave rise to Confederate ideology in the first place. Those sources – Mississippi’s Article of Secession, its 1890 Constitution, or the racist poison in the 1900s Hattiesburg Daily Progress – are not being rewritten. They speak for themselves. In order to develop our position, we have had to consult the original documents themselves – which is why we reprinted Stokes Robertson’s dedication speech two months ago, so you, today’s Mississippians, could see the language for yourselves.

We’re not rewriting history: we’re exposing it. This monument is evidence of history already being rewritten. The Lost Cause to which this monument is dedicated was an invention, an effort to portray 19th-century society in terms of the civilized white race and the savage black, of the antebellum period as the height of cultured progress and values. Any claim about what relocating Confederate monuments does “to history” only takes place in the context of the fact that these monuments were built to privilege one history – elite, white, Anglo history – over all others, first and foremost African-American history. Not to mention the fact that Hattiesburg and Forrest County were both formed after the Civil War.

In other words, when monument supporters claim that relocation constitutes an attack “on history,” we as historians – but really, as informed citizens – must respond: whose history? Not all histories have been equally told, particularly not those from the Jim Crow South – but the myth of the Lost Cause (and its modern incarnations) positions itself as the “true history,” a phrase that carries dangerous connotations, not least of self-righteousness and of dogmatic, insular thinking. We have a moral, professional, and civic obligation to stand against that.

Third, as for the flip side of that coin – that relocating the monument is erasing history? Monument supporters often put up a straw man to say that removal or relocation of monuments is tantamount to their destruction. To be blunt: we have never, not ever, taken that position, for the simple reason that destroying these monuments would prevent us from doing our job – and we have no interest in putting ourselves out of business. Job markets are tight enough as it is! No, to the contrary, we are arguing for its preservation, so that we can continue to learn from it: just not from a place of honor.

Argument #3: “It’s not hurting anyone.” To paraphrase Pope Francis, who are you to say? Do supporters of this claim have a window onto the psyche of human souls, to see those inner struggles the rest of us can’t? Not only is this claim deeply unsympathetic to the history of racial suffering, which is worrying enough, but it’s also historically untrue. Why else would the marchers on Freedom Day encircle this courthouse, this monument, as they sought their right to vote? Every Black or minority citizen who walks past this monument has to be reminded of a time when their ancestors were not citizens, when they were deemed to be second-class citizens, unworthy of participation in civic life and when white men and women waged a bloody war to preserve them not as fellow souls made in the image of God but as property. How can Americans today tolerate a shrine to such thinking in their midst? And how can anyone truly say – out of knowledge, not out of emotion or of ignorance – that such a monument causes no continued harm? And what does it say to Black kids today, for us to restate that we value the Confederacy more than we do them? Lastly, if it’s fair to ask who the monument hurts, then it’s also appropriate to ask: who does the monument really help? How does it benefit our society?

The other arguments against its relocation – namely, that it would be too expensive or too difficult – are further straw men. With the right political will, we’ve seen cities across the South remove their statuary safely, and there is no reason why Hattiesburg can’t do so as well. We know not every logistical question is worked out as we write this, but frankly, they don’t all have to be: first, let us make the right decision now. After that, we are confident that together with our elected officials, the people of Forrest County can find an amenable solution.

For finally, it is this last argument that takes us from the present day into a place we haven’t yet traveled: the future. Hattiesburg’s civic landscape belongs as much to our children and our grandchildren as it does to us – in some ways, more so – and this opportunity to promote racial healing may not arise again for many years. Look down the road for a moment, and imagine a young person of color, a Hattiesburg native born and raised, a recent graduate of her wonderful schools, walking down Main Street years from now. A young Black woman, say, getting ready to cast her very first ballot. Ask yourself: were she to ask you why that monument is still standing, how would you answer? How would you defend your decision to keep a reminder of second-class citizenship on the courthouse grounds? Why would anyone privilege an invented, hurtful past over the hope and promise of the present day – and of the future? There is no credible answer.

People of Forrest County, as you cast your ballots, we urge you to

send a clear message to the Board

of Supervisors, and vote yes,

the monument should be moved

to a more suitable location.

It’s time.

Dr. Benjamin Morris is the author of “Hattiesburg, Mississippi: A History of the Hub City” (The History Press, 2014). Professor William Sturkey is associate professor of history at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and the author of “Hattiesburg: An American City in Black and White” (Harvard University Press, 2019).

‹ PreviousNext ›

LOCAL SPORTS NEWS:

Lady Eagles torch UTSA in shooting frenzy 88-64

Southern Miss carried over the momentum of its first conference win of the season with a dominating… READ MORE

Oak Grove bounces back from first loss of season, wins Battle for the ‘Burg 89-68
155 - Guest Sumrall Soccer Coach Todd Siders
Nick Ammirati Named Southern Miss Baseball Assistant Coach
Sports Column: Drew Brees leaves an unforgettable Saints legacy. The story started in Jackson.
Sacred Heart girls soccer team's season ends due to COVID-19

 

121

Sign Up for Notifications of Local Breaking News

Start E-mail NotificationsStop E-mail NotificationsStart Mobile NotificationsStop Mobile Notifications

Most Read News Article

  • Week
  • Month
  • Year
  • All Time

Sacred Heart falls short to Our Lady of Academy in 3-2 loss

Sacred Heart fell short 3-2 in the rematch of last season’s South State Championship against… READ MORE

Sacred Heart girls soccer team's season ends due to COVID-19
Nick Ammirati Named Southern Miss Baseball Assistant Coach
155 - Guest Sumrall Soccer Coach Todd Siders
Oak Grove bounces back from first loss of season, wins Battle for the ‘Burg 89-68
City approves new, business-friendly draft of food truck ordinance

Southern Miss women’s basketball coach Joye Lee-McNelis diagnosed with stage 4 lung cancer

The Southern Miss women’s basketball game against UAB on Saturday was clouded with the news that… READ MORE

Oak Grove uses big third quarter to rout Petal 60-39
DiFATTA: ‘The rut’ has finally arrived for deer hunting
Meridian defeats Petal 60-50 to hand Panthers first loss of season
PODCAST: 153 - Recapping 2020, Looking at the New Year, Southern Miss & High School Basketball Action
Lady Eagles no match for UAB in 84-65 loss

2020 Best of the Pine Belt voting underway

Voting is now underway in FestivalSouth's 2020 Best of the Pine Belt competition, presented… READ MORE

Winston County Legals 062420
Bedford Care: 22 residents, five employees currently sick with COVID-19
PODCAST: 125 - Jason Munz Interview
ABADIE: I'm all in for Korean baseball; it's better than nothing
PODCAST: 126 - The future of sports in the Pine Belt & MLB Draft, Assessing the Saints' 2020 Schedule

2020 Best of the Pine Belt voting underway

Voting is now underway in FestivalSouth's 2020 Best of the Pine Belt competition, presented… READ MORE

Winston County Legals 062420
Political Cartoon: Jan. 23
Bedford Care: 22 residents, five employees currently sick with COVID-19
PODCAST: 125 - Jason Munz Interview
ABADIE: I'm all in for Korean baseball; it's better than nothing

PETAL NEWS

Forrest, Lamar conservation districts to celebrate Arbor Day with tree giveaways

Numbers provided by the Mississippi Forestry Commission show that the forestry industry in… READ MORE

NEWS FROM HATTIESBURG:

Judge signs consent decree between City of Hattiesburg, EPA and MDEQ over wastewater system

On Jan. 20, U.S.

18-wheeler strikes power poles in downtown Hattiesburg
Forrest, Lamar conservation districts to celebrate Arbor Day with tree giveaways
Hattiesburg to hit 75 miles in road paving with $1.5M invested in each ward since 2017
Pearl River Valley EPA to launch fiber-to-the-home network
Artists wanted to decorate city utility boxes around Hattiesburg

OPINION:

Fond memories of the American version of Paris, dairy farms and close encounters of the cow kind

Cows are much bigger up close.

Political cartoon for January 21
Political Cartoon for January 14
Days gone by and days to come
My Dorito Master
‘Ac-Cent-Tchu-Ate the Positive’

LOCAL CRIME NEWS:

Man to serve 40 years for murder of Emalee Walters of Eatonville

On Aug. 14, 2019, investigators with the Forrest County Sheriff’s Office were made aware of a… READ MORE

Hattiesburg Police Department Reports: January 8-10, 2021
Man arrested in Richton for Petal murder
Columbia man arrested with $80K worth of meth
Chicago woman for aggravated assault, firearm
Purvis man arrested for attempted rape on Longleaf Trace

 

lts

Copyright 2020 • HubCitySPOKES: A Publishing Company

525 N. Main St. • Hattiesburg, MS 39401 • 601.268.2331

Emmerich Newspapers proudly serve the following Mississippi communities:
Click on the city name to visit its website.

ACKERMAN • CARROLLTON • CHARLESTON • CLARKSDALE • COLUMBIA • EUPORA • FOREST • GREENVILLE • GREENWOOD • GRENADA • HATTIESBURG • JACKSON • KOSCIUSKO • INDIANOLA • LOUISVILLE • MAGEE • MENDENHALL • McCOMB • NEWTON • PETAL • QUITMAN • SENATOBIA • WINONA • YAZOO CITY

As well as: DUMAS, Ark. • TALLULAH, La • FRANKLINTON, La.

For more information on how to extend your advertising message to these communities, click here.